Validating Review Feedback

What problem does it solve?

Code review feedback can introduce scope creep or misinterpretations, derailing project plans. This Skill systematically validates feedback against the original plan, ensuring alignment and user-driven decisions on scope changes, saving you time and keeping projects on track.

Core Features & Use Cases

• Feedback Categorization: Classifies BLOCKING review items as in-scope, out-of-scope, or unclear against the implementation plan.
• User Decision Point: Prompts the user for explicit decisions on misaligned feedback (fix, reject, defer), ensuring user control over scope.
• Annotated Review & Plan Update: Tags review items with [FIX], [WONTFIX], [DEFERRED] and updates the plan with deferred items for clear tracking.
• Use Case: During a plan execution with review checkpoints, if a reviewer suggests a major refactoring not in the plan, this Skill will flag it as out-of-scope and ask the user whether to defer it, preventing unplanned work and maintaining project focus.

Quick Start

This Skill is typically invoked by an orchestrator agent

(e.g., the /execute command) after a code review.

It will:

1. Read the review and plan files.

2. Categorize BLOCKING feedback (in-scope, out-of-scope, unclear).

3. Ask you to decide on out-of-scope/unclear items (fix, reject, defer).

4. Annotate the review file and update the plan with deferred items.