review-writing

What problem does it solve? Academic authors often receive feedback that silently rewrites their prose, eroding their own voice, or vague comments that cannot be acted on. This Skill diagnoses problems in a draft and produces anchored, actionable comments while leaving the writing itself untouched. ## Core Features & Use Cases - Four-Pass Diagnosis: Runs separate passes over argument, structure, clarity, and consistency, quoting the exact sentences that fail each check. - Comments Only, No Rewriting: Produces critique the author can act on, preserving authorship of the text even when asked to "improve" it. - Anchored Reporting: Groups findings by pass with section and paragraph locations, quoting the offending text and stating what would fix it. - Use Case: Before sending a draft section to a co-author, run the review to catch unsupported causal claims, redundant paragraphs, stacked hedging, and inconsistent terminology. ## Quick Start Review the attached draft section of my paper and give me comments on its argument, structure, clarity, and consistency without rewriting anything.