review-paper
CommunityComprehensive manuscript review
Education & Research#academic publishing#manuscript review#econometrics#writing quality#referee report#research feedback
AuthorAndreaMentasti
Version1.0.0
Installs0
System Documentation
What problem does it solve?
This Skill provides a thorough, constructive review of academic manuscripts, simulating the feedback a top-tier journal referee would offer.
Core Features & Use Cases
- Argument Structure Evaluation: Assesses clarity, motivation, logical flow, and conclusion support.
- Identification Strategy Critique: Examines causal claims, assumptions, and threats to identification.
- Econometric Specification Review: Checks standard errors, functional form, sample selection, and estimator appropriateness.
- Literature Positioning Analysis: Verifies citation completeness, accurate characterization of prior work, and contribution differentiation.
- Writing and Presentation Quality: Evaluates clarity, concision, tone, notation consistency, and visual aids.
- Referee Objections Generation: Formulates critical questions a top referee would pose.
- Use Case: A researcher can submit a draft paper to this Skill to receive detailed, actionable feedback before journal submission, significantly improving the manuscript's quality and increasing acceptance chances.
Quick Start
Use the review-paper skill to review the manuscript located at master_supporting_docs/my_paper.tex.
Dependency Matrix
Required Modules
None requiredComponents
scriptsreferences
💻 Claude Code Installation
Recommended: Let Claude install automatically. Simply copy and paste the text below to Claude Code.
Please help me install this Skill: Name: review-paper Download link: https://github.com/AndreaMentasti/tweet-election/archive/main.zip#review-paper Please download this .zip file, extract it, and install it in the .claude/skills/ directory.
Agent Skills Search Helper
Install a tiny helper to your Agent, search and equip skill from 223,000+ vetted skills library on demand.