proposal-quality-review

Reviews proposal packages for requirement coverage, claim evidence, approval status, and submission readiness.

Updated Jun 21, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/lwokeray/cowork-plugins --skill proposal-quality-review-lwokeray
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent▼
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: proposal-quality-review
Source: https://github.com/lwokeray/cowork-plugins/tree/main/plugins/sales-cowork/skills/proposal-quality-review
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/lwokeray/cowork-plugins --skill proposal-quality-review-lwokeray

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve? Before submitting a proposal, RFP response, or client presentation, teams often miss uncovered requirements, unsupported claims, cross-document inconsistencies, or missing approvals. This Skill performs a structured quality review of a specific proposal version and produces an actionable Review Pack with a PASS, REVISE, or STOP verdict. ## Core Features & Use Cases - Requirement Traceability: Maps every customer requirement to a response location, evidence, owner, and status (Covered, Partially covered, Not covered, Conflict, Decision required, Not verifiable). - Claim and Citation Checking: Verifies every buyer-relevant claim against its source, version, and date, flagging unsupported or conflicting statements. - Multi-Gate Review Modes: Supports Blue, Pink, Red, Green, Gold, and submission-readiness review gates with distinct criteria for each stage. - Use Case: Before uploading a final RFP response, run a full review to confirm mandatory requirements are covered, pricing and legal approvals are valid for the current version, and the submission package meets format, deadline, and attachment rules. ## Quick Start Review the attached Contoso Proposal v5 against the RFP requirements and produce a verdict with findings, owners, and a submission readiness checklist.

Frequently Asked Questions about proposal-quality-review

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I review a proposal before RFP submission?▼

Provide the specific proposal version, the customer's RFP requirements, and submission instructions. The review checks requirement coverage, claim evidence, cross-document consistency, approvals, and submission readiness, then returns a PASS, REVISE, or STOP verdict with findings and owners.

What is a Red team review for proposals?▼

A Red review evaluates a near-final proposal from the evaluator's perspective, checking compliance, scoreability, clarity, differentiation, citations, contradictions, and unresolved comments. It goes beyond grammar fixes to verify every requirement is actually answered.

Can this review approve pricing or submit the proposal?▼

No. The review identifies missing or expired approvals for pricing, legal, security, SLA, and similar items, and routes them to named decision owners. It never approves commercial terms, signs off for managers, or performs the final submission.

What happens if the proposal version cannot be uniquely identified?▼

The review stops and lists candidate files with versions, locations, and modification times instead of forming a conclusion. A unique, readable version is a mandatory input before any verdict is issued.

How are unsupported claims in a proposal handled?▼

Each buyer-relevant claim is logged with its location, source, source date, and support status (Supported, Partial, Unsupported, Conflict). Claims stronger than their evidence must be narrowed, and internal confidential evidence is never exposed in client-facing versions.