peer-review-methodology

What problem does it solve?

This Skill provides a structured, comprehensive framework for evaluating scientific manuscripts and grant proposals, ensuring thoroughness and objectivity in the peer review process.

Core Features & Use Cases

• 7-Stage Evaluation: Guides reviewers through initial assessment, section-by-section review, statistical rigor, reproducibility, figure integrity, ethics, and writing quality.
• Reporting Standards: Checks compliance with CONSORT, STROBE, PRISMA, and other critical reporting guidelines.
• Use Case: A journal editor can use this Skill to train new reviewers or to ensure their experienced reviewers follow a consistent, high-quality evaluation process for all submitted manuscripts.

Quick Start

Use the peer-review-methodology skill to evaluate a submitted manuscript for statistical rigor and reproducibility.