paw-review-critic
CommunityMake PR feedback precise and actionable.
Authorlossyrob
Version1.0.0
Installs0
System Documentation
What problem does it solve?
This Skill helps reviewers and teams improve PR feedback by critically evaluating generated review comments for usefulness, accuracy, and appropriateness, ensuring decisions are well-supported by evidence.
Core Features & Use Cases
- Assessment engine: Reads ReviewComments.md and all related artifacts (GapAnalysis.md, CodeResearch.md, ImpactAnalysis.md, DerivedSpec.md) to form a comprehensive evaluation of each comment.
- Structured reasoning: Adds detailed assessments after each comment rationale, including usefulness, accuracy, alternative perspectives, trade-offs, and recommendations.
- Quality gate for posting: Produces clear guidance for whether a comment should be posted, modified, or skipped, and aggregates an iteration summary for auditability.
Quick Start
To begin, load the ReviewComments.md and supporting artifacts, generate internal assessments for every inline and thread comment, then append the assessments and an Iteration Summary to the document.
Dependency Matrix
Required Modules
None requiredComponents
Standard package💻 Claude Code Installation
Recommended: Let Claude install automatically. Simply copy and paste the text below to Claude Code.
Please help me install this Skill: Name: paw-review-critic Download link: https://github.com/lossyrob/phased-agent-workflow/archive/main.zip#paw-review-critic Please download this .zip file, extract it, and install it in the .claude/skills/ directory.
Agent Skills Search Helper
Install a tiny helper to your Agent, search and equip skill from 223,000+ vetted skills library on demand.