Orchestrates structured adversarial debates between two AI personas to stress-test plans and decisions.
npx skills add https://github.com/kridaydave/My_Skills --skill debate-kridaydave
Please help me install this Agent Skill. Skill: debate Source: https://github.com/kridaydave/My_Skills/tree/main/debate Command: npx skills add https://github.com/kridaydave/My_Skills --skill debate-kridaydave
High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.
Run a structured debate that pits two opposing personas against your plan or decision. Each side argues its strongest honest case across Opening and Rebuttal rounds, then a neutral synthesis delivers a verdict with what is settled, what is open, and the recommended call.
You can name two personas directly, or it auto-picks the natural opposition based on the artifact type. For example, architecture debates pair scale-focused versus ship-it lenses, while experiment designs pair rigor versus feasibility.
Steelmanning means each side must present the opponent's argument in its strongest form before attacking it. The debate prompts enforce this in the Rebuttal round, preventing strawman arguments that would make the debate worthless.
By default it runs two exchange rounds — Opening and Rebuttal — followed by a synthesis verdict. A third Counter round runs only if a genuine unresolved tension remains, so debates always converge to a decision rather than looping.
Use a debate when one perspective has blind spots that matter — high-stakes architecture choices, contested claims, or ambitious plans. A single review gives one lens; a debate exposes what survives genuine opposition and ends with a flip condition.
jdonohooChallenge proposal assumptions by arguing opposing positions to surface weaknesses.
nyldnInterrogates plans and designs one question at a time to expose flaws before commitment.
patricksavalleClassify empirical claims by evidence strength and methodological rigor.
austintheriotRoute user questions to a single consult-capable subagent for direct expert advice.
