critique-reviewer

Critique design and planning deliverables to produce risk notes and prioritized gap questionnaires.

Updated May 10, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/dadafinger/dadafinger-skills --skill critique-reviewer-dadafinger
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent▼
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: critique-reviewer
Source: https://github.com/dadafinger/dadafinger-skills/tree/main/critique-reviewer
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/dadafinger/dadafinger-skills --skill critique-reviewer-dadafinger

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

💡 This Skill includes references (resource) components.

What problem does it solve? Design and planning deliverables often ship with hidden risks, undefined behavior policies, and inconsistent terminology that surface too late. This Skill reviews Figma designs, design image folders, and meeting notes to expose only problems, risks, and gaps, then converts them into actionable decision documents. ## Core Features & Use Cases - Seven-category critique: Analyzes schedule/scope risk, requirement gaps, screen design issues, terminology inconsistency, governance risk, data/performance risk, and missing validation, with mandatory citations from meeting notes and design files. - Behavior Policy matrix: Maps undefined or ambiguous behavior policies across 8 domains (data aggregation, filters, charts, permissions, async/large data, state/exception handling, migration, operations/SLA) with recommended defaults. - Prioritized questionnaire: Generates a separate A-L section questionnaire with P0/P1/P2 priorities and answer fields that feed directly into a decision log. - Use Case: Given a Figma URL plus folders of design PNGs and meeting notes, the Skill reads all materials and saves two files, a critique note and a gap questionnaire, to a specified output path. ## Quick Start Critique the design folder and meeting notes folder for this project, exclude praise, analyze behavior policies, and save the critique note and questionnaire to my output folder.

Frequently Asked Questions about critique-reviewer

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I review a Figma design for risks and gaps?▼

Provide the Figma URL along with design image folders and meeting notes folders. The Skill reads all materials, produces a critique note covering seven risk categories, and generates a prioritized gap questionnaire saved as markdown files.

What inputs does a design critique workflow need?▼

It accepts one or more of: a Figma URL, a design image folder (PNG/JPG), a meeting notes folder (txt, rtf, UpNote, nested folders), and a planning document folder. Paths with spaces, parentheses, or Korean characters are supported.

What is a behavior policy matrix in design review?▼

It is a structured table covering 8 domains such as data aggregation, filters, charts, permissions, async handling, exception states, migration, and SLA. Each row records current status, a recommended default, and why a decision is needed.

What happens if the Figma URL cannot be accessed?▼

The Skill attempts to fetch the Figma URL, and if authentication or rendering fails, it explicitly notes the failure and falls back to analyzing the provided design PNG images instead.

When should I not use this critique workflow?▼

Do not use it for single-sentence copy review, code review, security review, validation bug triage, or manual formatting checks. Those cases belong to dedicated review skills; this one targets full design and planning deliverables.