What problem does it solve? Finished reports and briefs often ship with unsourced claims, overstated confidence, missing limitations, or vague next actions that a reviewer would catch immediately. This Skill runs a structured pre-publication self-critique so those defects are found and fixed before the document reaches its reader. ## Core Features & Use Cases - Fixed thirteen-point review: Scores ten base points (answers the question, evidence sourced, anti-patterns avoided, reproducible method, honest confidence, limitations stated, audience calibration, counter-evidence, defensible numbers, actionable next steps) plus three conditional points that fire only on specific document shapes. - Mechanical verdict: Derives an APPROVE, REVISE, or BLOCK verdict directly from the point statuses, with a located fix and pass condition for every non-passing point. - Use Case: A market brief claims a vendor is the "clear leader" with "60% YoY growth" but cites nothing. The critique blocks publication, flags the unsourced figures and missing limitations, and specifies exactly which sections to rewrite and what fixed looks like. ## Quick Start Use the critique-report skill to review my finished draft brief before I send it and tell me what a reviewer would catch.
