critic-pass

Validate drafts against task prompts for logical and factual errors.

Updated May 30, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/InnerScopeHearing/otchealth-claude-tools --skill critic-pass
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent▼
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: critic-pass
Source: https://github.com/InnerScopeHearing/otchealth-claude-tools/tree/main/skills/critic-pass
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/InnerScopeHearing/otchealth-claude-tools --skill critic-pass

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

💡 This Skill includes scripts (resource) components.

What problem does it solve?

This Skill provides a low-cost, high-ROI way to verify high-stakes deep-reasoning drafts, helping prevent costly mistakes before they reach the final stage.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Cheap Verification Loop: Conducts a cost-effective critic pass over draft outputs before they are committed.
  • Deep-Reasoning Drafts: Checks drafts for unsupported claims, logical gaps, missed constraints, and factual errors.
  • Use Case: Before committing architecture, migrations, or clinical analysis drafts, run the critic pass to catch potential issues early and reduce the risk of costly mistakes.

Quick Start

Use the critic-pass skill to check a draft by running: node critic.mjs prompt --task "<task>" --draft "<draft>"

Frequently Asked Questions about critic-pass

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I verify a deep-reasoning draft for logical and factual errors before committing?▼

To verify a deep-reasoning draft for logical and factual errors, you can run a critic pass using a script like `node critic.mjs` with your task and draft inputs to validate against unsupported claims and missed constraints.

What is the best way to check architectural proposals for missed constraints?▼

Checking architectural proposals for missed constraints is best done using a critic pass that operates in report-mode, logging unsupported claims and logical gaps without blocking the commit of your high-stakes output.

Does the critic pass script block the commit of high-stakes outputs?▼

The critic pass script does not block the commit of high-stakes outputs; it operates in report-mode, logging factual verification findings and logical errors so you can review potential issues early.

Do I need a specific model to run factual verification on drafts?▼

Running factual verification on drafts requires a Sonnet or llm_azure model to parse results and conduct the deep-reasoning checks needed to validate your task prompt against the draft.

When should I use a draft verification loop for my analysis drafts?▼

A draft verification loop should be used for high-stakes deep-reasoning tasks like financial analyses or migrations, providing a low-cost way to catch logical gaps and factual errors before final commitment.

Can I use this critic pass for clinical analysis draft verification?▼

You can use this critic pass for clinical analysis draft verification, as it is specifically intended for deep-reasoning components to identify unsupported claims and factual errors in high-stakes outputs.