council-review

Populates Agent Review Council runs with evidence-backed findings, scorecards, and validated artifacts.

Updated Jul 15, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/miethe/pediatric-anemia-site --skill council-review-miethe
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent▼
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: council-review
Source: https://github.com/miethe/pediatric-anemia-site/tree/main/.agents/skills/council-review
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/miethe/pediatric-anemia-site --skill council-review-miethe

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

💡 This Skill includes references (resource) components.

What problem does it solve? Coordinating a rigorous multi-reviewer audit of a product, codebase, architecture, or GTM artifact is hard to do consistently: findings lack evidence, reviewer outputs contaminate each other, and final reports miss required structure. This Skill turns a scaffolded ARC run skeleton into a complete, schema-validated review bundle. ## Core Features & Use Cases - Independent Reviewer Passes: Runs specialist, skeptic/red-team, and adjudicator passes in isolation so findings stay unbiased before synthesis. - Evidence-Gated Findings: Requires every finding to carry source locators, severity, confidence, and a validation method; unsupported claims stay hypotheses. - Schema-Valid Artifact Bundle: Produces evidence_pack.md, findings.yaml, scorecard.json, risk_register.yaml, decision_record.md, and validation_plan.md under runs/<date>-<slug>/, closed with uv run arc validate. - Use Case: After scaffolding a run with the council-run skill, ask the agent to review a new API design; it collects evidence, runs reviewer passes, adjudicates accepted/rejected/disputed/watchlist findings, and delivers a validated decision record. ## Quick Start Ask the agent to run a council review over the scaffolded run in runs/2026-06-22-api-design and produce the validated artifact bundle.

Frequently Asked Questions about council-review

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I run an Agent Review Council over a codebase or architecture?▼

First scaffold a run skeleton with the council-run skill or arc run, then invoke council-review to populate it. The skill builds an evidence pack, runs independent reviewer passes, adjudicates findings, and writes the full artifact bundle under runs/<date>-<slug>/.

What artifacts does an ARC run produce?▼

Every completed run contains evidence_pack.md, findings.yaml, scorecard.json, risk_register.yaml, decision_record.md, and validation_plan.md. The bundle must pass uv run arc validate before the run is considered closed.

What is the difference between council-run and council-review?▼

council-run scaffolds run skeletons, recommends councils, and authors council or reviewer-role YAML. council-review only populates an already-scaffolded run with evidence, reviewer passes, adjudication, and validated outputs.

Can I include external reviewers like Codex, GitHub Copilot, or LangGraph?▼

Yes, the references/external-reviewers.md guide covers non-Claude reviewers. Give them the same run contract, normalize their output into the finding schema, and never promote external findings to accepted until the adjudicator verifies evidence.

Does arc run execute the review automatically?▼

No, arc run only scaffolds an empty run skeleton plus a next_steps prompt and does not call an LLM. The council-review skill is how an agent populates the run in-session.

When should I not use council-review?▼

Do not use it for scaffolding runs, choosing councils, authoring council YAML, project binding, or rendering agent stubs; those belong to council-run. It also does not create tickets or durable memory without explicit approval.