ai-review-proposed-skills

Review and promote staged self-learned skill proposals through human approval gating.

Updated Feb 26, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/Vimurai/ai-os --skill ai-review-proposed-skills-vimurai
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent▼
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: ai-review-proposed-skills
Source: https://github.com/Vimurai/ai-os/tree/main/.claude/skills/ai-review-proposed-skills
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/Vimurai/ai-os --skill ai-review-proposed-skills-vimurai

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve? Self-learning systems that automatically extract reusable patterns from agent sessions create a safety risk if new skills activate without oversight. This Skill closes that gap by enforcing a human-in-the-loop review stage: staged proposals stay inert until an operator explicitly approves each one. ## Core Features & Use Cases - Proposal Enumeration: Lists all inert skill proposals staged under .claude/skills/proposed/ by the meta_analyst instinct-extraction process. - Human Approval Gate: Routes every promotion decision through approval-mcp, which blocks on an explicit terminal y/N response — self-approval and auto-promotion are impossible. - Defense-in-Depth Promotion: The promoter script independently re-verifies the APPROVED status, re-scans the skill body for dangerous content, and refuses to overwrite an already-active skill. - Use Case: After a week of agent sessions, the meta_analyst has staged three candidate skills. Run this Skill to inspect each proposal's pattern_id and confidence_score, approve the two trustworthy ones, and reject the third — with every decision logged for audit. ## Quick Start Ask the agent to review the proposed self-learned skills awaiting approval and promote only the ones you explicitly approve.

Frequently Asked Questions about ai-review-proposed-skills

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I review self-learned skill proposals before activation?▼

Invoke the review skill to enumerate everything staged under .claude/skills/proposed/. Each proposal's body, pattern_id, and confidence_score is shown, and promotion only proceeds after an explicit approval-mcp decision.

How does human-in-the-loop approval work for AI-generated skills?▼

Each proposal triggers an approval-mcp request_approval call that blocks on a terminal y/N prompt. The returned APPROVED or REJECTED decision object is passed directly to the promoter, which independently re-verifies the status before promoting.

Can self-learned skills auto-activate without human review?▼

No. Proposals staged by the meta_analyst are inert by design, and the promotion path requires an explicit approval-mcp APPROVED decision. The promoter re-verifies the decision and re-scans content, so auto-activation never happens.

What happens if a proposed skill contains dangerous content?▼

The promoter re-scans the skill body for dangerous content at promotion time as defense in depth, and rejects it if detected. Hand-editing a proposal to bypass the scan does not work because the scan runs again at promote time.

Why does skill promotion fail with a name collision?▼

The promoter refuses to overwrite an already-active skill with the same name. Resolve the collision first by renaming or removing the conflicting active skill, then re-run the promotion.